What is a Comfort Letter? A Guide for Startups Offering Employee Share Options

Explore how comfort letters establish a clear framework for offering share options, ensuring transparency and alignment between startups and prospective key employees.

Attracting top-tier talent is crucial for startups, particularly in their early stages, when every hire can significantly impact growth and success. However, with limited budgets, startups often need to get creative in making their employment offers attractive. One way they achieve this is by offering share options as part of an employee's compensation package.

A comfort letter is a document that sets out the company's intention to grant share options to a prospective employee. While it is not legally binding, it provides a clear and detailed outline of the proposed equity arrangement, building trust and confidence during the hiring process.

This article explores the role of comfort letters, how they fit into the broader framework of employee share options, and why they are essential for startups seeking to hire and retain key employees.

---

🎯 The Role of Share Options in Startups

Share options give employees the right to buy shares in the company at a pre-agreed price, usually at or below market value, after a certain period or upon meeting specific conditions.

For startups, share options are an excellent tool for:

• Compensating for Lower Salaries:
  Share options can help bridge the gap between market salaries and what the company can afford.

• Aligning Interests:
  By offering equity, employees are motivated to contribute to the company’s growth.

• Attracting Top Talent:
  Share options signal that the company values its team and is willing to share in future success.

In the UK, share options are often structured under the Enterprise Management Incentives (EMI) scheme, which provides tax advantages to both employees and employers. Comfort letters help introduce this concept to new hires.

---

📄 What is a Comfort Letter?

A comfort letter is a preliminary, non-binding document that outlines a startup’s intention to grant share options to a new or prospective employee.

It’s not a formal contract, but it sets the stage for a formal option agreement and the eventual establishment of an equity incentive scheme.

Think of it as the first step in the process of granting equity incentives. It builds confidence while allowing time for the necessary legal and regulatory steps, such as HMRC approval and drafting of full documentation.

---

✍️ What Does a Comfort Letter Typically Include?

A well-drafted comfort letter should include the following elements:

📊 Description of the Share Options

• Number of shares (or their approximate value).
• Exercise price (usually based on current market value).
• Whether the options fall under the EMI scheme or another arrangement.

⏳ Vesting Schedule

• Details of when and how options vest (e.g., monthly, annually, or upon specific milestones like an IPO or sale).
• Encourages long-term commitment and performance.

🚪 Good Leaver and Bad Leaver Provisions

• Defines who qualifies as a Good Leaver (e.g., redundancy, illness, death).
• Sets consequences for Bad Leavers (e.g., resignation or misconduct), who typically forfeit unvested options.

🧾 Tax and Legal Implications

• States that employees are responsible for any tax liabilities from exercising options.
• Encourages recipients to seek independent tax advice.

🚫 Non-Binding Nature

• Clearly indicates the letter is not legally binding.
• Confirms that any grant of share options is subject to board approval and the setup of a formal scheme.

---

🤝 How Does a Comfort Letter Benefit Startups and Employees?

✅ For Startups:

• Set Expectations: Clarifies the proposed equity arrangement early in the hiring process.
• Build Trust: Shows professionalism and transparency.
• Streamline Hiring: Allows flexibility and speed while the formal scheme is being prepared.

👥 For Employees:

• Offer Clarity: Helps the employee understand the value and mechanics of the offer.
• Provide Reassurance: Signals the company’s serious intent to share its success.
• Encourage Long-Term Thinking: Aligns employees with the startup’s future growth.

---

🧠 Additional Context: EMI Share Options and Startup Equity

The Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) scheme is the preferred option structure for UK startups due to its favourable tax treatment.

⚠️ Note: Both the company and the employee must meet certain eligibility criteria for EMI qualification. Comfort letters often anticipate EMI but are subject to these conditions.

---

🚀 Why Your Startup Needs to Use Comfort Letters

Startups compete with larger, well-funded companies for talent. Offering share options helps level the playing field, and comfort letters make it easier to introduce the concept early in the recruitment process.

A well-crafted comfort letter:

• Demonstrates commitment to rewarding your team.
• Provides clarity to potential hires.
• Enables faster hiring decisions without legal delays.